This is what I got with ~Library/mail. Still can't find the proper plist.
PersistenceInfo.plist
V4
0F7360FC-3368-4493-8BF1-19B92A821CED
2CB18F87-EB6D-4B66-8672-C873FD884111
08C8B47B-A379-4C56-B90E-CB075DDEFDB5
26280D0F-5F0F-47C8-8ACA-3905B0515B14
D553DB7E-E834-449D-B011-B4C8476CF00F
F6E7BEAC-9C39-48CE-B679-A86BD903145E
FC863C25-90CD-409C-8D25-3ABB7EACBFE9
MailData
BackupTOC.plist
DefaultCounts
Envelope Index
Envelope Index-shm
Envelope Index-wal
ExternalUpdates.storedata
ExternalUpdates.storedata-shm
ExternalUpdates.storedata-wal
FlagMailboxes.plist
LSMMap2
OpenedAttachmentsV2.plist
RulesActiveState.plist
Signatures
SmartMailboxesLocalProperties.plist
SyncedFilesInfo.plist
SyncedRules.plist
SyncedSmartMailboxes.plist
UnsyncedRules.plist
VIPSenders.plist
If you have problems getting to your user library, click the Go menu in Finder, select Go To Folder, and type (or paste) ~/Library. Then, press Return. (In case ~ is not easily visible on your screen, it's the tilde at the upper left of the keyboard, just below esc.)