I am using the current chicklet keyboard. Yes white does get dirty looking, but that is what keyboard cleaning swabs are for. The black keys or keyboards get just as dirty you just don't see it. Yes, as I said before, I wish there was more tilt but I have become accustomed to is being so flat (there are stands available and one would be easy enough to fabricate if it really bothered me that much, but hasn't been worth the cost or effort. The "Magic" keyboards have not had the problems that recent MacBook Pro keyboards have suffered from and in fact have a bit longer key travel. (I can vouch for that as I am using a "Magic" keyboard paired with a MacBook Pro so both are immediately at hand.)
CAVEAT:
This is MY experience and I make no assertion yours WILL be the same. I am hypothesizing yours MAY be similar. This is a situation where taste/preferences/choices are highly individualistic.
