I use 1Blocker/1Blocker Button and "Enable Content Blockers" in Safari 11.0.1 makes a significant difference on many sites. It is sometimes the difference in a correctly rendered page and a blank window or just text running down the left margin, or even more often whether clicking on a link will work or not.
I don't know the details of how AdBlock
vis-a-vis 1Blocker, but this seems to be a subject worthy of further exploration.
Whew! Tax season is finally over!
I took a look at 1Blocker, and I might even be inclined to overlook my aversion to the App Store for a trial d/l, but it doesn't offer one. (I've been a big fan of AdBlock because of its ability to block ANY html element on a web page, NOT just ads, but 1Blocker sounds like it offers similar functionality.)
I occasionally run into problems with my AdBlock/Ghostery combo that require me to use Safari > Develop > Disable Extensions, and I've got a few websites whitelisted in AdBlock, but I've never kept close track of the details that a good comparison of ad blockers would require, and it's a more daunting task than I'd care to get involved in, so your question will go unanswered forever...by me, at least.
And, of course, it's not just an AdBlock v 1Blocker issue, because there's a plethora of ad blockers out there, and they all claim to be the best.
Getting back to my initial question, though, I'm wondering why unchecking "Enable Content Blockers" doesn't yield the same results as "Disable Extensions"; is it a bug or a very basic lack of understanding of the two options on my part?